Tuesday, November 30, 2010

My Teenage Dream

Remember the Glee episode when Kurt visits the Dalton Academy and meets up with Blaine, who sings him Teenage Dream with all the other boys of the school? I liked that. After that show aired, my friend Ansley sent me this review of that episode. Tom and Lorenzo, the authors of the post, discuss that as fantastic as the "It Get's Better" project is, it only goes so far. Unfortunately, kids get their cues on what's normal and acceptable from the media. Here's what T&L have to say:

To the straight people reading us: remember high school? Remember your favorite songs and movies, TV shows and music videos from that period? Imagine if all of that media bombardment telling you what to like, what to wear, and how to be attractive, popular, and cool, imagine that all of that aimed for and addressed everyone else but you. Imagine what it's like when every sappy love song (or angry breakup song), every rom com, every trendy TV show and blockbuster movie, even every video game, imagine if they all depicted a form of romantic love that simply isn't available to you. Imagine going through high school without even so much as a hint of yourself reflected in any of the things you watch and listen to, any of the things that literally every other kid is talking about. Imagine the one thing you want more than anything in the world: to be kissed, please god, just to be kissed, imagine you have never seen that depicted anywhere or referred to in any way but as something to be mocked and shunned.

This is why the "Teenage Dream" sequence was so incredibly powerful. I remember getting lots of chills when I watched it, but the strange thing is that it didn't fully occur to my why it was giving me the chills it was until after I read the blog post above. But it's true. It was thrilling to see something depicted that I could actually relate too. I think I was also kind of annoyed that it was giving me chills and that I liked it so much because it was so damn cheesy. But it was allowing me to experience, by proxy, unlived teenage dreams.

This point was driven home even further last night when several Mormon young single adult congregations in the Portland area had a joint activity that was what they called a "Charity Date Auction." The title is a little bit misleading. It was actually a date auction for charity and not an auction of charity dates.

Anyway, I wasn't really planning on going. I meet with a trainer on Monday nights, so I wouldn't have been able to get there until well after it started. Plus there's the fact that I would have probably just ended up being annoyed by the whole thing. Lately though, I've been learning to experience such things while wearing the hat of a cultural anthropologist. When I do, these experiences become more interesting and somewhat less annoying.

So I went and caught part of the auction wearing my anthro hat. Sadly, it was a silent auction. I think a live auction (is that what they're called?) would have been so much more entertaining. I was envisioning something more along the lines of the date auction in Groundhog Day. It was interesting though to go and listen to what I was feeling. There was a sense of interest on my part to witness what was going on and to just sit back and observe in a fairly detached way.

I realized though as I left that I had this semi latent feeling of jealousy and longing. The energy in the air from good natured, sexually repressed Mormon twenty-somethings having a forum to express possible romantic interest in each other was incredibly tangible. Pretty much any Mormon young single adult event is infused with this energy: the excitement of possibly meeting someone you might like, or learning about someone who might be interested in you, the dread of having someone you're not interested in try to hit on you.

The energy is there and it's thick and I've almost never been able to experience it personally or feel a part of it in those settings. Early on, before I came to terms with my attraction to men, I probably would have just identified the inability as me being different somehow and that it was my problem that I had a hard time fitting myself into those scenes. It didn't occur to me that maybe those scenes weren't providing what I needed or hungered for, or that maybe I was so lost in what I was supposed to like and do that my own God given instincts and internal voice (the spirit) was getting completely drowned out.

I also realize that this experience of not feeling like you fit in, whether being a gay Mormon at a young single adult activity or anything else, isn't exclusive to gay Mormons. I'm curious what other experiences people have had with not feeling like you fit in with what was being portrayed around you, whatever the circumstance. How did you process it, grow from it or learn more about what your actual needs are, etc.? Or maybe you're still in the stage of being able to identify that you don't feel like you fit in somewhere that you think you should, but you can't exactly put your finger on why that is. How do you go about getting in touch with yourself enough to be able to start to understand where the discomfort comes from and what it can tell you about who you are and what your needs are?

14 comments:

  1. I felt out of place and had an existential crisis at the Saudi Quaker Little People's Vegan Dungeon S&M Convention. Does that count?

    ...OK, OK, I don't have the energy to do homework on your post but wanted to say I liked reading it. :-)

    And I also laughed at myself as I felt a certain giddiness watching that scene, all the while thinking, "This is the fruitiest thing I've seen in a month." I knew I "should" be able to relate to male-female romance, and I "shouldn't" identify with characters based primarily or solely on their gender or orientation. Love is love, right? But there's just something more 'real' about seeing such interaction between two guys, even if I don't identify with their personalities per se.

    A friend of mine is annoyed that Glee seems to be becoming "the Kurt show," but I explained that it's probably largely an honest attempt to respond in a positive and uplifting way to the current social climate, reaching out to a demographic which has essentially only a marginal place in general media--gay teens--and will taper off. He seemed to acknowledge that.

    On a related note, I think a lot of the time, those of us who are more quietly going about our lives go overboard in apologizing or getting defensive on behalf of others when a TV show "goes gay" or features gay characters in anything other than an incidental or stereotyped way. I think many of us are afraid of possible--or likely--backlash, and we want to make sure everyone knows we're not pushing...oh, gosh, I should just go write my own post. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. always felt like I was on the outside looking in. Still do. Pretty much everywhere. How do I deal with it? Good question.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mandi, maybe you should become a smartass like O-Mo.

    Seriously though, I was at that convention and I didn't see you. I call your bluff. Or was this your way of getting me to out myself as a lover of Saudi Quaker Little People? Shoot...

    I've had the same thoughts about Glee becoming the Kurt show. I'm sure there are many who think that Glee is a tool of Hollywood demons trying to push the "gay agenda" and turn us all gay. I think the storyline with Kurt has developed fairly organically as a response to the current climate and I think for the most part it's great. Sure it can be a little bit melodramatic, but we're talking about high school gays. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. OH hey i dont watch this glee you speak of (since i prefer shows like DESPAIR follows the terminally ill gothic misfit kids who are in a debate team who sucks horribly. They have no wild card, and their teacher is clinically depressed.)

    but i never really fit in at church activities... even like "bad" mormons still hang out with plenty of their kind. I just look at them and think "What LAME-anites!" and i want to smite them. jk.

    but srs. it was the stupidest idea ive ever had to go to utah.

    ReplyDelete
  5. jon i hope you actually have an anthripologist hat. like the man in the yellow hat in curious george.

    i always hated those activities they make me feel like all we are to eachother is potential "mates". or makeout buddies. but maybe some people need that expeirence as part of their journey getting to know themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I had a very lovely evening of rumination over this question and I have come up with an answer. However, I don't think this is the forum for it. But I thank you for nudging me down the path.
    And nobody does "smartass" like O-mo.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm such a misunderstood creature.

    Great, now I'm feeling alienated and out of place here, too.

    Actually, I've also felt like an outsider everywhere I went, including family gatherings, my whole life, too, except for a brief stint of unusual social conformity in my early twenties which temporarily masked it within local LDS singles circles, where I was a bit of a ringleader and social facilitator.

    A conversation last night definitely accentuated my "differentness" from the rest of my family. It's still really frustrating sometimes that the people I most wish "got it" just clearly don't understand what's going on inside of me, what motivates me, and what I value let alone why I value it so much, but still believe I should just follow tried-and-true formulas for happiness which have worked for them (they are staunchly concrete, formulaic thinkers...something I've drafted a post about...so many drafts...). Fortunately, I started to realize how differently I thought and how I valued things in different priorities from others, and I stopped allowing predominant value prioritization to make me doubt myself and feel compelled to reform my values to match what seems to be the norm. I gained an appreciation for the fact that I don't have an interest in living in a world where everyone follows the same formulas whether or not they are personally happy doing so just because they seem to work for a majority. I realized I don't believe perfect society consists of making sure everyone prioritizes values the same way. I realized I'm not just an anomaly, or a caveat, or a quaint exception that 'has to be dealt with' but have the opportunity to really drive change, progress, and openness by owning myself and my differences and believing they have inherent, intrinsic value and aren't "rebellion" or "quirks" that need to be subdued or kept in check any more or less than supposedly predominant values or traits do.

    I imagined a world in which people like me were the majority, and of course it's refreshing. ...for a minute. And then I realize how very alienated and diminished people like my family members might easily feel in such a world, and the pitfalls their perspectives would help us avoid, and I shrug and say, "Hey, until some fantastical perfect balance is reached, someone has to be the odd man out. Guess it's me for now." And I go find friends who seem to "get it" and build social networks to remind myself I'm not alone.

    Hm...did I just do homework on this? @#$%.

    ReplyDelete
  8. So here's the interesting thing. I've found that the more I listen to my inner voice for cues instead of others, it makes for both a more lonely and less lonely experience. It becomes less lonely because I'm connecting with myself and my needs and fulfilling them and life starts to have a resonance and rhythm. At the same time though, it becomes more lonely because I'm not depending on other more well worn paths to take my cues from. There's something that feels dangerous and risky about venturing down the path of individuation. The more I venture down that path, the fewer examples I see around me showing me how to be me, which I see as a good thing. Sure, I still communicate with others and get input from others, but more and more I realize that ultimately it falls to me to create my happiness. It's fantastic because it puts me in control, but at the same time it has its incredibly lonely moments.

    I think if more people opened themselves up to that degree of individuation, it might alienate and diminish others who depend on social cues and group think, but maybe it would also show them that they can do the same. Then I think we'd be a much more vibrant and alive tapestry than we currently are.

    ReplyDelete
  9. wait, you meet with a trainer?!?

    ReplyDelete
  10. That's what I took away from this too KPW.

    I kid, I kid. I was interested in the "it gets better" movement but I only watched a few videos. What gets better? I don't know if it works to say, it will get better because out there is a gay utopia where boys like Blaine sing to you. I would say it gets better because you stop caring about what other people think and learning to be comfortable with who you are. Life really didn't get better when I became free to have a crush on a guy like Blaine or socialize with the gays. I don't feel at home in gay social circles anymore than I do in Mormon ones. Life gets better because you find a few people out there who love you for who are and you get to spend time with them.
    Is that too off-base?

    ReplyDelete
  11. How dare you, CJW. Just kidding. I think that's a good point. It's not like it gets so better that you're life becomes a magical gay fantasy with rainbows and unicorns and teen heart throbs singing you love songs.

    ReplyDelete
  12. So did your bid for the EQ president win?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ya know, Jon, if you could stop writing posts that stay in my head for days afterward, it would make my life easier. :) (but less awesome, so keep doing it!) I finally decided the easier question would be whether I've ever felt like I did belong or fit in... Because the answer would be simply no, not really. And for me, the more I know I'm supposed to belong , the harder it is. Being lonely when I'm home alone in Oregon seems reasonable enough. But when I'm lonely at my family's house, it's rather painful. Being one of many Mormons in Utah was hard for me, but going to work now and being The Mormon, no big deal. I think it's easier because I get to define the role however I feel good about, and nobody is going to judge me for doing it right or wrong. I also don't mind being the young, single girl among all the older marrieds at work, whereas being around YSAs reminds me that I'm a loser who isn't playing the dating game like everyone else. The disability community is so divided, and I mean that on all kinds of levels, it's hard to feel a true sense of belonging there, though there's an element of it. Not gonna lie, I often crave that secure sense of fitting in and being with my tribe. But a lot of my sense of self has come from the ways I'm different from those around me. Just like the fish who would have to leave the water to ever know what water is. Like I didn't understand English before learning Spanish. And I learn about American/white culture by getting to know other cultures. I guess I really am a diversity lover... Perhaps by necessity. :)

    ReplyDelete